A Wisconsin prosecutor has cleared a Madison police officer of criminal charges in the fatal shooting of 38-year-old Corey Ruiz, who wielded a knife during a confrontation with law enforcement last July. The decision has sparked immediate backlash from the victim’s family and their attorney, Ben Crump, despite video evidence showing Ruiz armed and resisting arrest.
The Legal Standard Applied
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne determined that officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted within legal boundaries when he fired three shots at Ruiz during the July 22 incident. The prosecutor reviewed multiple video sources, police reports, and witness statements before concluding the officer’s response was reasonable under Wisconsin law. Ruiz had resisted officers, produced a knife, and remained unaffected by multiple Taser deployments before the shooting occurred at a busy Madison intersection.
Ozanne emphasized his duty to apply existing law equally to all citizens, regardless of their profession. The district attorney stated that officers do not forfeit their right to self-defense when confronting armed suspects who pose an immediate threat. Police dash-camera footage clearly shows Ruiz holding the knife with the blade pointed downward as officers repeatedly shouted warnings to each other about the weapon.
Family Claims Excessive Force
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, representing the Ruiz family, characterized the incident as an execution and called it one of the worst cases of excessive force he has encountered. Crump claims the medical examiner indicated Ruiz would have survived the first two shots but died from a third round that struck his head. The family rejected the prosecutor’s decision, with Ruiz’s brother Adam telling reporters they feel destroyed and will not accept the outcome.
Officer Baitinger-Peterson told investigators he grabbed Ruiz’s right arm before realizing the suspect held a knife. He stated he feared Ruiz would stab the responding officers and fired the third shot because Ruiz’s facial expression and body showed no reaction to the initial rounds, leading him to believe they had missed their target. The officer sustained minor injuries to both hands during the struggle.
What This Means for Law Enforcement
The decision reinforces legal protections for officers facing armed suspects who resist lawful commands and deploy weapons. Wisconsin law permits deadly force when officers reasonably believe their lives or others’ lives face immediate danger. The incident began with calls about someone checking parked cars and attempting a burglary. Four officers responded and surrounded Ruiz, who was on a bicycle, before the confrontation escalated. The Wisconsin Professional Police Association’s executive director stated the prosecutor’s decision aligns with established legal standards governing use of force.
Sources
Nbcnews: Prosecutor declines to charge Wisconsin police officer who fatally shot a Black man

