A missing Democratic candidate remains on the November ballot in Nassau County after Republicans successfully sued to block his replacement, exposing how legal technicalities can manipulate electoral outcomes.
Republican Legal Maneuvering Blocks Ballot Replacement
Nassau County Republicans exploited New York election law to prevent Democrats from fielding a viable candidate after Petros Krommidas disappeared. The GOP filed suit arguing Krommidas could not be removed from the ballot without an official death declaration, despite his family’s presumption of death. This legal strategy effectively eliminates competitive opposition for Republican incumbent Patrick Mullaney, demonstrating how parties manipulate procedural rules for electoral advantage rather than serving voters’ interests.
Missing Candidate’s Tragic Disappearance
Krommidas, a 29-year-old first-generation American and former Ivy League rower, vanished April 23 during a nighttime swim off Long Beach while training for a triathlon. Extensive searches by family, volunteers, and authorities recovered only his belongings from the beach. The Democratic candidate for Nassau County Legislature District 4 was known for community involvement before his disappearance. His case highlights the intersection of personal tragedy and political calculations in local elections.
Electoral Law Creates Unprecedented Ballot Situation
New York’s strict election statutes require official death declarations before candidate removal, creating an extraordinary situation where a missing person remains on the ballot. Legal experts note the rarity of such cases and the rigid requirements that prevent practical solutions. The judge’s ruling prioritized legal technicalities over democratic representation, leaving voters with a potentially meaningless choice. This precedent could prompt needed reforms to prevent future electoral manipulation through procedural exploitation.
A political candidate in the New York City suburbs went for a night swim in the Atlantic Ocean this past spring and never returned.
Petros Krommidas’ phone, keys and clothes were found on the sands at Long Beach on Long Island. The 29-year-old former Ivy League rower, who was… pic.twitter.com/DupYO8kLGE
— Yahoo News (@YahooNews) October 13, 2025
Community Response and Democratic Dilemma
Krommidas’ family encourages voting for their missing son as a tribute and to trigger a potential special election if he wins. Former Democratic colleague James Hodge supports this strategy, believing it offers the only path to legitimate representation. However, this approach risks confusing voters and undermining the democratic process. The situation demonstrates how emotional appeals can sometimes conflict with practical governance needs, leaving constituents without clear representation in their local government.
Sources:
Political candidate missing at sea remains on ballot for upcoming election
A candidate disappeared months ago after an ocean swim. He could still win the election
Missing Long Island politician’s name will still appear on ballot